Skip to content

Controversy over pogy boats in Louisiana waters rages on

NEW ORLEANS (WVUE) – A bit of over a quarter-mile off Scofield Island, the industrial boat “Kittiwake” fishes for menhaden, generally known as “an important fish within the sea.”

Additionally referred to as pogy and fatback, menhaden are by far Louisiana’s largest fishery, producing upwards of 500 million tons per 12 months. That is greater than shrimp, crabs, and oysters mixed. Many of the fish are floor up into fertilizer, pet meals, and fish oil dietary supplements.

Two vegetation in Louisiana and one in Mississippi grind the fish right into a protein powder used as feed for livestock and in aquaculture.

“Proper now, it is just like the wild west out right here,” constitution boat captain Eric Newman says.

Pogies are additionally the main target of a dispute between the business and sport fishermen, together with complaints from each side concerning the different incessantly intruding on their house within the water.

Industrial menhaden fishing is banned in Florida and Alabama utterly. Mississippi will not permit it inside a mile of its shores. Texas has half-mile and one-mile buffers and a strict catch restrict.

“Right here in Louisiana, we have not too long ago carried out a laughable one-quarter-mile buffer,” David Cresson with the Coastal Conservation Affiliation says. “We have been exterior a quarter-mile right this moment and you may see the harm that was being performed in these shallow areas.”

To haul of their catch, pogy boats dispatch two smaller boats that unfurl a 1,700-foot-long web. They draw the top collectively and fold the underside of the web to seize the fish, that are then vacuumed into the mom boat.

Wherever there may be fishing, there may be the potential for bycatch – the incidental seize of non-target species.

“These species which might be caught as bycatch are usually not prized recreation fish. It is extra your crocker, your mullet,” Ben Landry with Omega Protein says.

The 2 sides level to totally different figures in the case of bycatch, however the numbers are within the 1-3% vary.

Newman is among the many critics, involved the boats scoop up extra than simply pogies.

“There must be an even bigger buffer zone,” Newman says.

“Every part out right here eats pogies,” Chris Macaluso of the Theodore Roosevelt Conservation Partnership says. “… dolphins, sharks, particularly bull redfish this time of 12 months.”

Pogy boat captain Mike Dameron says the bars on the top of the boat’s vacuum hose, and extra slim gaps up high, stop bigger fish from getting into the maintain.

“Larger fish that make it by way of will hit these collection of bars after which be discharged again overboard to sea,” Dameron says.

Even some fish that keep away from getting sucked into the boat find yourself dying, however there aren’t any actual numbers.

“I’ve by no means seen them make a set – and I’ve seen them make a whole lot of units – the place they did not kill some massive redfish,” Macaluso says.

“The redfish and speckled trout that we hear our critics say is basically minute quantities in comparison with what leisure anglers are eradicating from the water,” Landry says.

“We predict it is unfair that our livelihoods, and the livelihoods of hundreds of people who exist on this business, is being unfairly challenged with none scientific proof to help it,” Kuttel says.

FILE — Frozen and salted menhaden sit in a barrel at a lobster bait warehouse, Thursday, Oct....
FILE — Frozen and salted menhaden sit in a barrel at a lobster bait warehouse, Thursday, Oct. 19, 2017, in Portland, Maine. (AP Picture/Robert F. Bukaty, File)(Robert F. Bukaty | AP)

During the last couple of years, Louisiana lawmakers got here near putting tighter restrictions on the pogy boats, limiting their catch, however the payments ultimately died.

“It is a query of sharing the financial worth of the coast. We consider there’s nothing that we do that’s difficult the livelihood of anybody, not a industrial constitution boat captain, not a leisure fisherman,” Francois Kuttel, proprietor of Westbank Fishing in southern Plaquemines Parish, says.

In late October, the pogy boats are wrapping up their season.

“You are popping out right here and also you’re seeing these fish which might be right here to breed, getting killed and thrown again within the water useless. It is actually arduous for the common man to not have his abdomen turned by seeing that,” Macaluso says.

“Once more, you have to take a look at the impression of the quantity of fish that we do catch. And are they not fishing the redfish through the time these fish are spawning?” Kuttel asks.

The Louisiana Wildlife and Fisheries Fee not too long ago moved towards enacting stricter leisure limits on speckled trout amid indicators the species’ numbers are dropping.

“It is person battle. Individuals do not need to see the massive dangerous industrial fisherman on the market on the water. Business fishing constructed this nation,” Dameron says.

General, the business says it creates 800 direct jobs and pumps $500 million into the economic system, nevertheless it’s shrinking. There are solely about one-third as many boats as there have been within the Eighties.

“By pushing us out, they’re gonna problem our economics. They are going to bankrupt us,” Kuttel says.

Kuttel says the disputed space nearer to shore quantities to twenty% of their catch.

“We fish the place we fish as a result of that is the place the fish is,” Kuttel says.

However there are different points, like deserted nets.

Final month, a pogy boat close to Holly Seashore dumped an estimated 900,000 kilos of menhaden – most of them useless.

“And there is a regulation, which we help, we aren’t opposed, which is able to place an onus on us to ensure that incidents like that don’t occur sooner or later and in the event that they do, that we’re penalized,” Kuttel says.

That is additionally, to a sure diploma, a philosophical disagreement about Louisiana’s coast, how we use it, and the dearth of white sand seashores and vacationers.

“The Louisiana shoreline is essentially totally different than these of, for instance, Mississippi, the place it’s dotted with inns from one facet to the opposite,” Kuttel says.

“Our seashores are simply as essential if no more essential. Our seashores have all been restored with oil spill cash. We spent a billion {dollars} on restoring these seashores on this a part of the state,” Macaluso says.

Each side speak of compromise, however that has confirmed elusive because the controversy over Louisiana’s largest fishery rages on.

See a spelling or grammar error in our story? Click on Right here to report it. Please embrace the headline.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *